The Perfect Girl by Gilly Macmillan ~ Fiction Book Review

The Perfect Girl: A Novel by [Macmillan, Gilly]I really liked this author’s other book, “What She Knew”. It had a great twist that I never saw coming and impressed me enough that I gave this one a try when I came across it and recognized the author’s name.

This book was good, but it pales in comparison to the other. It felt mundane and erred on the side of the predictable. The characters weren’t as vivid. The stakes didn’t feel as high. That sense of ‘wow’ and breathlessness that her other book left me with was completely absent here. It was good, but not in the way that makes you take notice and remember the author’s name. 4 stars.

What She Knew by Gilly MacMillan ~ Fiction #Book Review

25817531This book is about a boy who runs ahead of his mom in the woods, and disappears. Scary because it happens so quick. Scary, because the mother not only has to deal with her fear for her missing child, but also the fallout from the media and the scathing  scrutiny of the public who judge her every move and decision. Scary, because what happens in this book is possible. Everything on the pages combines to create a reality that leaves the reader tense and breathless.

Gilly MacMillan is definitely an author to keep an eye on. What She Knew, her debut novel, is a taut, suspenseful ride that kept me guessing until the very end. I found myself wishing I could stay up late to finish the last 80 pages. The writing is deep, insightful and poignant. 5 stars.


Create a website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: